SB2258 - 104th General Assembly
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | AMENDMENT TO SENATE BILL 2258 | ||||||
| 2 | AMENDMENT NO. ______. Amend Senate Bill 2258, AS AMENDED, | ||||||
| 3 | by replacing everything after the enacting clause with the | ||||||
| 4 | following: | ||||||
| 5 | "Section 1. Short title. This Act may be referred to as the | ||||||
| 6 | Thermal Energy Network and Jobs Act. | ||||||
| 7 | Section 5. Legislative findings and intent. | ||||||
| 8 | (a) The General Assembly finds and declares that: | ||||||
| 9 | (1) This State has a strong interest in ensuring that | ||||||
| 10 | emissions of greenhouse gases from buildings are reduced | ||||||
| 11 | because buildings are one of this State's largest sources | ||||||
| 12 | of greenhouse gases due to the combustion of fossil fuels | ||||||
| 13 | for heating, domestic hot water production, cooking, and | ||||||
| 14 | other end uses. | ||||||
| 15 | (2) The decarbonization of buildings must be pursued | ||||||
| 16 | in a manner that is affordable and accessible, preserves | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | and creates living-wage jobs, and retains the knowledge | ||||||
| 2 | and experience of the existing utility union workforce. | ||||||
| 3 | (3) Thermal energy networks have the potential to | ||||||
| 4 | decarbonize buildings at the community and utility scale | ||||||
| 5 | and help achieve the goals of Public Act 102-662 (also | ||||||
| 6 | known as the Climate and Equitable Jobs Act). | ||||||
| 7 | (4) Thermal energy networks consist of pipe loops | ||||||
| 8 | between multiple buildings and energy sources, which carry | ||||||
| 9 | water and can be connected to by building owners to | ||||||
| 10 | support heating and cooling and hot water services. | ||||||
| 11 | Building owners can connect to the loops to support water | ||||||
| 12 | heating and cooling and hot water services. | ||||||
| 13 | (5) Many utilities in this State have been seeking to | ||||||
| 14 | develop thermal energy networks but have encountered legal | ||||||
| 15 | and regulatory barriers. | ||||||
| 16 | (6) This State has a strong interest in ensuring an | ||||||
| 17 | adequate supply of reliable electrical power and, | ||||||
| 18 | therefore, needs to promote the development of alternative | ||||||
| 19 | power sources and take steps to assure reliable | ||||||
| 20 | deliverability. Thermal energy networks are highly | ||||||
| 21 | efficient because they use and exchange thermal energy | ||||||
| 22 | from many underground sources and buildings, including | ||||||
| 23 | recycled thermal energy, which minimizes impacts on the | ||||||
| 24 | electricity grid. | ||||||
| 25 | (7) Access to thermal energy networks has the | ||||||
| 26 | potential to reduce the upfront and operating costs of | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | building electrification for customers. | ||||||
| 2 | (8) Thermal loop technology provides benefits to | ||||||
| 3 | participants and non-participants alike, including | ||||||
| 4 | societal benefits to the environment and the market | ||||||
| 5 | benefits associated with the reduction of both the volume | ||||||
| 6 | and peak demand of electricity and natural gas. | ||||||
| 7 | (9) A utility's access to capital, the utility's | ||||||
| 8 | experience with networked infrastructure in public | ||||||
| 9 | rights-of-way, and the requirement that the utility serve | ||||||
| 10 | all customers positions the utility well to develop and | ||||||
| 11 | scale thermal energy networks that are accessible to all | ||||||
| 12 | customers and to coordinate the development of thermal | ||||||
| 13 | energy networks with any orderly rightsizing of the | ||||||
| 14 | utility gas system. | ||||||
| 15 | (10) This State also has an interest in the efficient | ||||||
| 16 | and reliable delivery of energy and the energy | ||||||
| 17 | infrastructure of the State, which interest is | ||||||
| 18 | acknowledged throughout the Public Utilities Act. Utility | ||||||
| 19 | corporations and other power suppliers share these | ||||||
| 20 | interests and, moreover, have a duty to protect | ||||||
| 21 | proprietary interests in the projects they fund. Such | ||||||
| 22 | investments of ratepayer resources can be protected by | ||||||
| 23 | establishing effective contractor qualification and | ||||||
| 24 | performance standards, including requirements for | ||||||
| 25 | prevailing wage rates, bona fide apprenticeship criteria, | ||||||
| 26 | and project labor agreements. | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | (11) The construction industry is highly skilled and | ||||||
| 2 | labor intensive, and the installation of modern thermal | ||||||
| 3 | energy networks involves particularly complex work. | ||||||
| 4 | Therefore, effective qualification standards for craft | ||||||
| 5 | labor personnel employed on these projects are critically | ||||||
| 6 | needed to promote successful project delivery. | ||||||
| 7 | (12) Finally, these findings are especially vital now | ||||||
| 8 | because the construction industry is experiencing | ||||||
| 9 | widespread skill shortages across the country, which are | ||||||
| 10 | crippling existing capital projects and threatening | ||||||
| 11 | projects planned for the future. The construction of | ||||||
| 12 | thermal energy networks will utilize many of the same | ||||||
| 13 | skills that the current utility and building trades | ||||||
| 14 | workforces already possess. | ||||||
| 15 | (b) It is the intent of the General Assembly that passage | ||||||
| 16 | of this Act is for the following purposes: | ||||||
| 17 | (1) to remove the legal barriers to utility | ||||||
| 18 | development of thermal energy networks and require the | ||||||
| 19 | Illinois Commerce Commission, within 90 days after the | ||||||
| 20 | effective date of this amendatory Act of the 104th General | ||||||
| 21 | Assembly, to begin to authorize and direct utilities to | ||||||
| 22 | immediately commence piloting thermal energy networks in | ||||||
| 23 | each and every utility territory; | ||||||
| 24 | (2) to direct and authorize the Illinois Commerce | ||||||
| 25 | Commission to develop a regulatory structure for utility | ||||||
| 26 | thermal energy networks that scales affordable and | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | accessible building electrification, protects customers, | ||||||
| 2 | and balances the role of incumbent monopoly utilities with | ||||||
| 3 | other market and public actors; | ||||||
| 4 | (3) to promote the successful planning and delivery of | ||||||
| 5 | thermal energy networks and protect critical investments | ||||||
| 6 | in such projects by requiring the use of appropriate | ||||||
| 7 | quality craft labor policies that ensure the development | ||||||
| 8 | of and access to an adequate supply of well trained, | ||||||
| 9 | highly skilled craft persons needed to support timely, | ||||||
| 10 | reliable, high-quality projects; | ||||||
| 11 | (4) to promote strong economic development and good | ||||||
| 12 | jobs for local residents in the expanding decarbonized | ||||||
| 13 | sector by requiring application of progressive State labor | ||||||
| 14 | and employment policies that ensure public utility | ||||||
| 15 | investments and related State subsidies create | ||||||
| 16 | unparalleled skill training and employment opportunities | ||||||
| 17 | for residents in project areas through the use of local | ||||||
| 18 | prevailing wage standards and successful, bona fide | ||||||
| 19 | apprenticeship programs or project labor agreements that | ||||||
| 20 | incorporate prevailing wage and training standards and | ||||||
| 21 | provide additional benefits for project owners and | ||||||
| 22 | workers; and | ||||||
| 23 | (5) to promote the use of preapprenticeship programs | ||||||
| 24 | that will fortify and expand existing apprenticeship | ||||||
| 25 | programs through systematic outreach efforts to recruit | ||||||
| 26 | and assist persons from underrepresented and low income | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | communities by providing such persons with remedial | ||||||
| 2 | education, social services, and unique opportunities for | ||||||
| 3 | direct access into high-quality apprenticeship programs | ||||||
| 4 | and gainful employment in the growing building | ||||||
| 5 | decarbonization workforce. | ||||||
| 6 | Section 10. The Public Utilities Act is amended by | ||||||
| 7 | changing Section 3-101 and by adding Sections 3-128, 3-129, | ||||||
| 8 | 3-130, 3-131, and 8-513 as follows: | ||||||
| 9 | (220 ILCS 5/3-101) (from Ch. 111 2/3, par. 3-101) | ||||||
| 10 | Sec. 3-101. Definitions. Unless otherwise specified, the | ||||||
| 11 | terms set forth in Sections 3-102 through 3-131 3-126 are used | ||||||
| 12 | in this Act as therein defined. | ||||||
| 13 | (Source: P.A. 97-96, eff. 7-13-11; 97-239, eff. 8-2-11; | ||||||
| 14 | 97-813, eff. 7-13-12.) | ||||||
| 15 | (220 ILCS 5/3-128 new) | ||||||
| 16 | Sec. 3-128. Thermal energy. "Thermal energy" means piped | ||||||
| 17 | noncombustible fluids used for transferring heat into and out | ||||||
| 18 | of buildings for the purpose of reducing any resultant onsite | ||||||
| 19 | greenhouse gas emissions of all types of heating and cooling | ||||||
| 20 | processes, including, but not limited to, comfort heating and | ||||||
| 21 | cooling, domestic hot water, and refrigeration. | ||||||
| 22 | (220 ILCS 5/3-129 new) | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | Sec. 3-129. Thermal energy network. "Thermal energy | ||||||
| 2 | network" means all real estate, fixtures, and personal | ||||||
| 3 | property operated, owned, used, or to be used for, in | ||||||
| 4 | connection with, or to facilitate a utility-scale distribution | ||||||
| 5 | infrastructure project that supplies non-combusting thermal | ||||||
| 6 | energy. "Thermal energy network" includes real estate, | ||||||
| 7 | fixtures, and personal property that is operated, owned, or | ||||||
| 8 | used by multiple parties. | ||||||
| 9 | (220 ILCS 5/3-130 new) | ||||||
| 10 | Sec. 3-130. Front-of-meter work. "Front-of-meter work" | ||||||
| 11 | means a thermal energy network project that impacts the | ||||||
| 12 | utility side of a meter. | ||||||
| 13 | (220 ILCS 5/3-131 new) | ||||||
| 14 | Sec. 3-131. Behind-the-meter work. "Behind-the-meter work" | ||||||
| 15 | means a thermal energy network project that involves a | ||||||
| 16 | physical, operational, or behavioral modification to the | ||||||
| 17 | customer side of a utility meter, including the replacement of | ||||||
| 18 | appliances, retrofits, and panel upgrades. | ||||||
| 19 | (220 ILCS 5/8-513 new) | ||||||
| 20 | Sec. 8-513. Pilot thermal energy network development. | ||||||
| 21 | (a) Within 10 months after the effective date of this | ||||||
| 22 | amendatory Act of the 104th General Assembly, every gas public | ||||||
| 23 | utility or combination public utility serving over 100,000 | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | customers shall file with the Commission a petition seeking | ||||||
| 2 | Commission approval of a proposed pilot thermal energy network | ||||||
| 3 | project. A gas public utility or combination public utility | ||||||
| 4 | may seek Commission approval of one additional proposed pilot | ||||||
| 5 | thermal energy network project each year for 2 years after the | ||||||
| 6 | effective date of this amendatory Act of the 104th General | ||||||
| 7 | Assembly. Designs for the projects should coordinate and | ||||||
| 8 | maximize the value of existing State energy efficiency and | ||||||
| 9 | weatherization programs and take advantage of federal funding | ||||||
| 10 | opportunities to the extent practicable. No later than 18 | ||||||
| 11 | months after the effective date of this amendatory Act of the | ||||||
| 12 | 104th General Assembly, the Commission shall enter an order | ||||||
| 13 | approving, approving with modification, or rejecting each | ||||||
| 14 | proposed pilot thermal energy network project and shall direct | ||||||
| 15 | the public utility to implement the pilot thermal energy | ||||||
| 16 | network projects as approved or approved as modified. In | ||||||
| 17 | considering whether to approve or approve as modified each | ||||||
| 18 | pilot thermal energy network project, the Commission shall | ||||||
| 19 | consider whether the pilot thermal energy network project is | ||||||
| 20 | in the public interest, whether the pilot thermal energy | ||||||
| 21 | network project will develop information useful for the | ||||||
| 22 | Commission in adopting rules governing thermal energy | ||||||
| 23 | networks, whether the pilot thermal energy network project | ||||||
| 24 | furthers climate justice and emissions reduction, whether the | ||||||
| 25 | pilot thermal energy network project advances financial and | ||||||
| 26 | technical approaches to equitable and affordable building | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | electrification, and whether the pilot thermal energy network | ||||||
| 2 | project creates benefits to customers and society at large, | ||||||
| 3 | including, but not limited to, public health benefits in areas | ||||||
| 4 | with disproportionate environmental or public health burdens, | ||||||
| 5 | job retention and creation, reliability, and increased | ||||||
| 6 | affordability of renewable thermal energy options. After the | ||||||
| 7 | filing of a petition, a utility may request the Commission to | ||||||
| 8 | grant additional time for pilot development approval, which | ||||||
| 9 | shall be approved for at least 6 months upon request or up to | ||||||
| 10 | 12 months upon a showing that additional time would benefit | ||||||
| 11 | pilot development. An electric public utility may also propose | ||||||
| 12 | a pilot thermal energy network project in accordance with this | ||||||
| 13 | subsection (a). | ||||||
| 14 | (b) If a utility proposes 3 pilot thermal energy network | ||||||
| 15 | projects, at least one project shall be proposed in | ||||||
| 16 | economically disadvantaged communities as defined in Section | ||||||
| 17 | 5-35 of the Energy Transition Act and at least one shall | ||||||
| 18 | include an industrial heat application that may additionally | ||||||
| 19 | include residential and commercial applications. Priority | ||||||
| 20 | shall be given to pilot proposals that replace leak-prone | ||||||
| 21 | natural gas distribution infrastructure with distribution | ||||||
| 22 | infrastructure that supplies non-combusting thermal energy or | ||||||
| 23 | that replaces thermal energy for buildings currently heated | ||||||
| 24 | with electric resistance heat. Each public utility shall | ||||||
| 25 | coordinate with other public utilities and consultants with | ||||||
| 26 | expertise on successful pilot projects to ensure that the | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | pilot projects are diverse and designed to inform the | ||||||
| 2 | Commission's decisions in the proceeding on the various | ||||||
| 3 | ownership, market, and rate structures for thermal energy | ||||||
| 4 | networks. The pilot project proposals shall be made publicly | ||||||
| 5 | available on the Commission's website. Utilities are | ||||||
| 6 | encouraged to develop plans that enable and facilitate access | ||||||
| 7 | to thermal loop technology benefits, including access by low | ||||||
| 8 | and moderate income households. As part of any pilot project | ||||||
| 9 | proposed pursuant to this Section, a public utility subject to | ||||||
| 10 | this Section may propose to include customer rebates and | ||||||
| 11 | incentives, and associated tariffs and proposed regulatory | ||||||
| 12 | treatment, in a manner similar to what is included in | ||||||
| 13 | Commission-approved electric energy efficiency plans pursuant | ||||||
| 14 | to Section 8-103B of this Act. | ||||||
| 15 | (b-5) Each public utility proposing a pilot thermal energy | ||||||
| 16 | network project shall hold at least one prefiling public | ||||||
| 17 | meeting to receive public comment concerning the proposed | ||||||
| 18 | thermal energy network in the municipality where the thermal | ||||||
| 19 | energy network is to be located. Notice of the public meeting | ||||||
| 20 | shall be published in a newspaper of general circulation for 3 | ||||||
| 21 | consecutive weeks, beginning no earlier than one month prior | ||||||
| 22 | to the first public meeting. Notice of the public meeting, | ||||||
| 23 | including a description of the thermal energy network, must be | ||||||
| 24 | provided in writing to the clerk of the county where the | ||||||
| 25 | project is to be located and to the chief clerk of the | ||||||
| 26 | Commission. A representative of the Commission shall be | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | invited to each prefiling public meeting. | ||||||
| 2 | (c) Any gas public utility, electric public utility, or | ||||||
| 3 | combination public utility constructing or operating a | ||||||
| 4 | Commission-approved pilot thermal energy network project shall | ||||||
| 5 | report to the Commission, on a quarterly basis and until | ||||||
| 6 | completion of the pilot thermal energy network project, as | ||||||
| 7 | determined by the Commission, the status of each pilot thermal | ||||||
| 8 | energy network project. The Commission shall post and make | ||||||
| 9 | publicly available the reports on its website. The report | ||||||
| 10 | shall include, but not be limited to: | ||||||
| 11 | (1) the stage of development of each pilot project; | ||||||
| 12 | (2) the barriers to development; | ||||||
| 13 | (3) the number of customers served; | ||||||
| 14 | (4) the costs of the pilot project; | ||||||
| 15 | (5) the number of jobs retained or created by the | ||||||
| 16 | pilot project; and | ||||||
| 17 | (6) other information the Commission deems to be in | ||||||
| 18 | the public interest or considers likely to prove useful or | ||||||
| 19 | relevant to the rulemaking described in subsection (h). | ||||||
| 20 | (c-5) The Commission shall require projects submitted to | ||||||
| 21 | the utility-scale renewable thermal energy network program for | ||||||
| 22 | approval to include a proposed rate structure for thermal | ||||||
| 23 | energy services supplied to network end users and consumer | ||||||
| 24 | protection plans for end users. The Commission may approve the | ||||||
| 25 | proposed rate structure if the projected heating and cooling | ||||||
| 26 | costs for end users is not greater than the heating and cooling | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | costs the end users would have incurred if the end users had | ||||||
| 2 | not participated in the program. | ||||||
| 3 | (d) Any gas public utility, electric public utility, or | ||||||
| 4 | combination public utility constructing or operating a | ||||||
| 5 | Commission-approved pilot thermal energy network project shall | ||||||
| 6 | demonstrate that it has entered into a labor peace agreement | ||||||
| 7 | with a bona fide labor organization that is actively engaged | ||||||
| 8 | in representing its employees. The labor peace agreement shall | ||||||
| 9 | apply to the employees necessary for the ongoing maintenance | ||||||
| 10 | and operation of the thermal energy network. The labor peace | ||||||
| 11 | agreement shall be an ongoing material condition of | ||||||
| 12 | authorization to maintain and operate the thermal energy | ||||||
| 13 | networks. | ||||||
| 14 | (e) Any contractor or subcontractor that performs work on | ||||||
| 15 | a pilot thermal energy network under this Section shall be a | ||||||
| 16 | responsible bidder as described in Section 30-22 of the | ||||||
| 17 | Illinois Procurement Code and shall certify that not less than | ||||||
| 18 | prevailing wage, as determined under the Prevailing Wage Act, | ||||||
| 19 | was or will be paid to employees who are engaged in | ||||||
| 20 | construction activities associated with the pilot thermal | ||||||
| 21 | energy network project. The contractor or subcontractor shall | ||||||
| 22 | submit evidence to the Commission that it complied with the | ||||||
| 23 | requirements of this subsection. | ||||||
| 24 | (f) For any pending application for a thermal energy | ||||||
| 25 | network, the contractor or subcontractor shall submit evidence | ||||||
| 26 | that the contractor or subcontractor has entered into a fully | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | executed project labor agreement with the applicable local | ||||||
| 2 | building trades council for the front-of-meter and | ||||||
| 3 | behind-the-meter work required for the thermal energy network. | ||||||
| 4 | The Commission shall not approve any pending applications | ||||||
| 5 | until the contractor or subcontractor has submitted the | ||||||
| 6 | information required under this subsection. | ||||||
| 7 | (g) Within 4 years after the effective date of this | ||||||
| 8 | amendatory Act of the 104th General Assembly, the Commission | ||||||
| 9 | shall adopt rules to, at a minimum: | ||||||
| 10 | (1) create fair market access rules for thermal energy | ||||||
| 11 | networks to accept thermal energy and that do not increase | ||||||
| 12 | greenhouse gas emissions or copollutants; | ||||||
| 13 | (2) to the extent it is in the public interest to do | ||||||
| 14 | so, exempt small-scale thermal energy networks from active | ||||||
| 15 | regulation by the Commission; | ||||||
| 16 | (3) promote the training and transition of utility | ||||||
| 17 | workers impacted by this amendatory Act of the 104th | ||||||
| 18 | General Assembly; and | ||||||
| 19 | (4) encourage third-party participation and | ||||||
| 20 | competition where it will maximize benefits to customers. | ||||||
| 21 | (h) A gas public utility or combination public utility | ||||||
| 22 | required to develop any pilot thermal energy network project | ||||||
| 23 | under this Section shall be permitted to recover all | ||||||
| 24 | reasonable and prudently incurred costs associated with the | ||||||
| 25 | development, construction, and operation of one or more pilot | ||||||
| 26 | thermal energy network projects through general rates set | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | pursuant to Section 9-201 or through rates set in a Multi-Year | ||||||
| 2 | Rate Plan pursuant to Section 16-108.18. A gas public utility, | ||||||
| 3 | electric public utility, or combination public utility | ||||||
| 4 | developing a thermal energy network project that includes an | ||||||
| 5 | industrial heat application may recover rates proportionally | ||||||
| 6 | from each class of customer. The Commission shall have broad | ||||||
| 7 | discretion in approving proposed pilot projects that are | ||||||
| 8 | consistent with the public interest consistent with this | ||||||
| 9 | Section and in approving all tariffs and issuing other | ||||||
| 10 | regulatory approvals as necessary to permit a pilot program | ||||||
| 11 | that facilitates a full review of technologies, and associated | ||||||
| 12 | policies, with respect to thermal network technology in this | ||||||
| 13 | State. An electric utility or a utility that offers both gas | ||||||
| 14 | and electric service that is required to submit an integrated | ||||||
| 15 | grid plan shall include any proposed pilot programs under this | ||||||
| 16 | Section as part of the proposed grid plan pursuant to Section | ||||||
| 17 | 16-105.17 and shall inform stakeholders of the proposed pilot | ||||||
| 18 | programs during the stakeholder process that precedes the | ||||||
| 19 | filing of the grid plan. Any obligation imposed by this | ||||||
| 20 | Section on a utility shall be suspended pending a review of the | ||||||
| 21 | proposed grid planning process. If the Commission (i) | ||||||
| 22 | determines that the investments required to comply with this | ||||||
| 23 | Section impair customer affordability or (ii) does not approve | ||||||
| 24 | the proposed pilot programs, the requirements of this | ||||||
| 25 | subsection (i) shall be suspended until the Commission | ||||||
| 26 | approves recovery under a proposed pilot program in a future | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | integrated grid plan or Multi-Year Rate Plan. | ||||||
| 2 | (i) The total cost of implementation and administration of | ||||||
| 3 | thermal energy network projects shall not exceed $25,000,000 | ||||||
| 4 | in a given year. If projects exceed the cost limitation under | ||||||
| 5 | this subsection (i), the Commission shall immediately suspend | ||||||
| 6 | new applications and prioritize the continuation of existing | ||||||
| 7 | participants' benefits under this Section as funds permit. | ||||||
| 8 | Section 97. Severability. If any provision of this Act or | ||||||
| 9 | its application to any gas public utility, electric public | ||||||
| 10 | utility, or combination public utility constructing or | ||||||
| 11 | operating a Commission-approved pilot thermal energy network | ||||||
| 12 | project is determined to be invalid or otherwise | ||||||
| 13 | unenforceable, such determination shall not affect the | ||||||
| 14 | validity or enforceability of any other provision of this Act, | ||||||
| 15 | which shall continue in full force and effect. | ||||||
| 16 | Section 99. Effective date. This Act takes effect upon | ||||||
| 17 | becoming law.". | ||||||
