|
Sen. Graciela Guzmán
Filed: 4/15/2026
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | AMENDMENT TO SENATE BILL 2202
|
| 2 | | AMENDMENT NO. ______. Amend Senate Bill 2202, AS AMENDED, |
| 3 | | by replacing everything after the enacting clause with the |
| 4 | | following: |
| 5 | | "Section 1. Short title. This Act may be cited as the |
| 6 | | Academic Freedom of Expression Act. |
| 7 | | Section 3. Findings and legislative intent. |
| 8 | | (a) The General Assembly finds that: |
| 9 | | (1) Institutions of higher education are essential |
| 10 | | forums for the open exchange of ideas that foster the free |
| 11 | | search for truth, robust debate, and innovation, which |
| 12 | | benefits this State. Academic freedom is indispensable to |
| 13 | | this mission and therefore warrants statutory protection. |
| 14 | | (2) Academic freedom serves not only individual |
| 15 | | interests but also the broader public interest by |
| 16 | | safeguarding the independence and integrity of teaching, |
|
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | - 2 - | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | learning, and scholarship, which are vital to the economic |
| 2 | | and cultural well-being of the State. |
| 3 | | (3) The exercise of academic freedom may be threatened |
| 4 | | by external pressures, including actions by public |
| 5 | | officials or governmental bodies that seek to influence or |
| 6 | | restrict teaching, research, or expression. Such actions |
| 7 | | undermine the mission of higher education and are contrary |
| 8 | | to the public interest. |
| 9 | | (b) The General Assembly encourages the governing board of |
| 10 | | each post-secondary educational institution, as defined in the |
| 11 | | Private College Act, to adopt or amend institutional policies |
| 12 | | that incorporate, at a minimum, the academic freedoms, rights, |
| 13 | | and obligations for public institutions of higher education |
| 14 | | set forth in Section 8 of the Public Higher Education Act. The |
| 15 | | General Assembly further encourages each private |
| 16 | | post-secondary educational institution to make the |
| 17 | | institution's policies on academic freedom, if applicable, |
| 18 | | publicly available on the institution's website. |
| 19 | | Section 5. The Public Higher Education Act is amended by |
| 20 | | adding Section 8 as follows: |
| 21 | | (110 ILCS 167/8 new) |
| 22 | | Sec. 8. Academic freedom. |
| 23 | | (a) As used in this Section: |
| 24 | | "Harassment" means conduct directed at a particular |
|
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | - 3 - | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | individual or group that is so severe, pervasive, and |
| 2 | | objectively offensive that it effectively denies a person |
| 3 | | equal access to a public institution of higher education's |
| 4 | | educational programs or activities, consistent with applicable |
| 5 | | federal and State law. |
| 6 | | "Hate crime" has the meaning given to that term in Section |
| 7 | | 12-7.1 of the Criminal Code of 2012. |
| 8 | | "Intimidation" means a course of conduct directed at a |
| 9 | | particular individual or group that would cause a reasonable |
| 10 | | person to fear for their physical safety or the physical |
| 11 | | safety of others and that is not protected by the First |
| 12 | | Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, consistent |
| 13 | | with applicable federal and State law. |
| 14 | | "Threat" means a statement or course of conduct made with |
| 15 | | knowledge or reckless disregard that a reasonable person would |
| 16 | | interpret as a serious expression of intent to commit an act of |
| 17 | | unlawful violence against a particular individual or group, |
| 18 | | consistent with applicable federal and State law. |
| 19 | | (b) Every faculty member of a public institution of higher |
| 20 | | education has the right to all of the following, without fear |
| 21 | | of direct or indirect retaliation by the institution or |
| 22 | | discipline up to and including termination: |
| 23 | | (1) Freedom in teaching, including the right to select |
| 24 | | pedagogical methods, course materials, and forms of |
| 25 | | assessment and to present and freely discuss the subject |
| 26 | | matter of course material, as long as such methods, |
|
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | - 4 - | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | materials, forms of assessment, and discussions are |
| 2 | | relevant to the course content and conducted consistent |
| 3 | | with lawful institutional policies and standards of the |
| 4 | | discipline. |
| 5 | | (2) Freedom in research, including the right to |
| 6 | | pursue, produce, publish, and disseminate |
| 7 | | scholarship-related research, subject only to professional |
| 8 | | ethics standards, lawful institutional policies and |
| 9 | | responsibilities, contractual obligations, and applicable |
| 10 | | laws and regulatory requirements governing research |
| 11 | | activities. |
| 12 | | (3) Freedom of expression, where the faculty member is |
| 13 | | acting in an individual capacity and does not purport to |
| 14 | | represent the views of the institution unless the faculty |
| 15 | | member is authorized to do so, on matters of public |
| 16 | | concern, including the right to comment on institutional, |
| 17 | | local, State, or federal policies, practices, governance, |
| 18 | | or administration. This freedom shall be exercised in a |
| 19 | | manner consistent with applicable laws. |
| 20 | | (4) Freedom to attend a political rally or public |
| 21 | | demonstration, as long as the faculty member is not absent |
| 22 | | from class or other official responsibilities, and to |
| 23 | | write or publicly comment on political issues or related |
| 24 | | topics, as long as the faculty member is acting in an |
| 25 | | individual capacity outside the scope of their assigned |
| 26 | | institutional duties and without the use of institutional |
|
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | - 5 - | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | resources, consistent with applicable law and lawful |
| 2 | | institutional policies. |
| 3 | | Nothing in this Section shall be construed to create an |
| 4 | | inconsistent or unequal application of lawful institutional |
| 5 | | policies governing expressive activity among faculty, staff, |
| 6 | | or other employees of the public institution of higher |
| 7 | | education, except as necessary to account for differences in |
| 8 | | assigned institutional responsibilities. |
| 9 | | (c) Every student of a public institution of higher |
| 10 | | education has the right to all of the following, without fear |
| 11 | | of direct or indirect retaliation by the institution or |
| 12 | | discipline: |
| 13 | | (1) Freedom to freely discuss the subject matter of |
| 14 | | teaching material in the classroom, as long as such |
| 15 | | discussion is relevant to the course content, conducted |
| 16 | | consistent with lawful institutional policies, and in |
| 17 | | conformity with the class management expectations |
| 18 | | established for the applicable class. |
| 19 | | (2) Freedom in research, including the right to |
| 20 | | pursue, produce, publish, and disseminate |
| 21 | | scholarship-related research, subject only to applicable |
| 22 | | ethics standards, lawful institutional policies, |
| 23 | | contractual obligations, and laws and regulatory |
| 24 | | requirements governing research activities. |
| 25 | | (3) Freedom of expression on matters of public |
| 26 | | concern, including the right to comment on institutional, |
|
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | - 6 - | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | local, State, or federal policies, practices, governance, |
| 2 | | or administration. This freedom shall be exercised in a |
| 3 | | manner consistent with lawful institutional policies and |
| 4 | | applicable laws. |
| 5 | | (4) Freedom to attend a political rally or public |
| 6 | | demonstration and to write or publicly comment on |
| 7 | | political issues or related topics. |
| 8 | | (d) This Section may not be construed to: |
| 9 | | (1) prevent this State or a public institution of |
| 10 | | higher education from enacting generally applicable |
| 11 | | academic standards, degree requirements, or governance |
| 12 | | structures developed through established |
| 13 | | shared-governance processes; |
| 14 | | (2) limit compliance with federal or State civil |
| 15 | | rights, health and safety, or fiduciary laws; |
| 16 | | (3) supersede any valid collective bargaining |
| 17 | | agreement provisions that afford equal or greater |
| 18 | | protection; |
| 19 | | (4) limit the authority of an institution of higher |
| 20 | | education to regulate the speech or expressive conduct of |
| 21 | | faculty, staff, or students to the extent permitted under |
| 22 | | federal or State law, including through reasonable |
| 23 | | content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral time, place, and |
| 24 | | manner restrictions and the regulation of speech in |
| 25 | | nonpublic forums; |
| 26 | | (5) restrict an institution's ability to clarify that |
|
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | - 7 - | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | speech or expression by faculty, staff, or students is |
| 2 | | undertaken in an individual capacity and does not |
| 3 | | represent the views of the institution unless the faculty, |
| 4 | | staff, or students were expressly authorized by the |
| 5 | | institution; or |
| 6 | | (6) prohibit an institution from adopting and |
| 7 | | enforcing policies addressing unlawful harassment, |
| 8 | | discrimination, threats, intimidation, hate crimes, or |
| 9 | | conduct that materially and substantially disrupts the |
| 10 | | functioning of the institution or that interferes with the |
| 11 | | rights of others to participate in or benefit from |
| 12 | | institutional programs or activities, consistent with |
| 13 | | federal and State law. |
| 14 | | (e) No State officer or employee, member of a State |
| 15 | | governing or coordinating board, or institutional |
| 16 | | administrator may penalize any faculty member of a public |
| 17 | | institution of higher education concerning the specific |
| 18 | | content of, viewpoints presented in, or method of the faculty |
| 19 | | member's teaching or scholarship, except as necessary to |
| 20 | | ensure that a faculty member's teaching or scholarship is |
| 21 | | reasonably germane to the faculty member's field or fields of |
| 22 | | study or assigned instructional responsibilities and that |
| 23 | | non-germane speech does not comprise a substantial portion of |
| 24 | | classroom instruction or to comply with applicable law. |
| 25 | | (f) The governing board of each public institution of |
| 26 | | higher education shall, by July 1, 2027, adopt or amend |
|
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | - 8 - | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | institutional policies to incorporate, at a minimum, the |
| 2 | | rights and obligations set forth in this amendatory Act of the |
| 3 | | 104th General Assembly, in consultation with recognized |
| 4 | | faculty governing bodies and, if applicable, collective |
| 5 | | bargaining representatives. |
| 6 | | Each public institution of higher education shall make the |
| 7 | | institution's policies on academic freedom publicly available |
| 8 | | on the institution's website by July 1, 2027 and within 60 days |
| 9 | | after any subsequent revisions to the policy. |
| 10 | | Each public institution of higher education shall submit |
| 11 | | the institution's policies on academic freedom to the Illinois |
| 12 | | Community College Board or the Board of Higher Education, |
| 13 | | whichever is applicable, by July 1, 2027 and within 60 days |
| 14 | | after any subsequent revisions to the policy. The Illinois |
| 15 | | Community College Board and the Board of Higher Education |
| 16 | | shall make the policies received from each institution under |
| 17 | | this subsection (f) publicly available on their respective |
| 18 | | websites by January 1, 2028 and within 60 days after any |
| 19 | | subsequent revisions to the policy. The Illinois Community |
| 20 | | College Board and the Board of Higher Education shall each |
| 21 | | submit to the General Assembly a report compiling the policies |
| 22 | | received from each institution under this subsection (f) by |
| 23 | | January 1, 2028. |
| 24 | | (g) Alleged violations of this Section shall first be |
| 25 | | addressed through an institution's established grievance or |
| 26 | | administrative review procedures or applicable collective |
|
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | - 9 - | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | bargaining agreements. A faculty member or student of an |
| 2 | | institution at the time that the institution has made or |
| 3 | | enforced any rule in violation of this Section may commence a |
| 4 | | civil action to obtain appropriate injunctive and declaratory |
| 5 | | relief as determined by a court if the faculty member or |
| 6 | | student has first exhausted applicable institutional grievance |
| 7 | | or administrative review procedures or remedies available |
| 8 | | under any applicable collective bargaining agreement. Upon |
| 9 | | motion, the court shall award reasonable attorney's fees and |
| 10 | | costs, including expert witness fees and other litigation |
| 11 | | expenses, to a prevailing plaintiff in a civil action brought |
| 12 | | under this Section. Nothing in this Section shall be construed |
| 13 | | to create a private right of action for damages against an |
| 14 | | institution. |
| 15 | | Section 15. The Public Community College Act is amended by |
| 16 | | changing Section 2-15 as follows: |
| 17 | | (110 ILCS 805/2-15) (from Ch. 122, par. 102-15) |
| 18 | | Sec. 2-15. Recognition. The State Board shall grant |
| 19 | | recognition to community colleges which maintain equipment, |
| 20 | | courses of study, standards of scholarship and other |
| 21 | | requirements set by the State Board. Application for |
| 22 | | recognition shall be made to the State Board. The State Board |
| 23 | | shall set the criteria by which the community colleges shall |
| 24 | | be judged and through the executive officer of the State Board |
|
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | - 10 - | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | shall arrange for an official evaluation of the community |
| 2 | | colleges and shall grant recognition of such community |
| 3 | | colleges as may meet the required standards. |
| 4 | | Recognition shall include a review of a community |
| 5 | | college's compliance with Section 8 of the Public Higher |
| 6 | | Education Act. Recognition shall also include a review of |
| 7 | | compliance with Section 3-65 of this Act and other applicable |
| 8 | | State and federal laws regarding employment contracts and |
| 9 | | compensation. Annually, the State Board shall convene an |
| 10 | | advisory committee to review the findings and make |
| 11 | | recommendations for changes or additions to the laws or the |
| 12 | | review procedures. |
| 13 | | If a community college district fails to meet the |
| 14 | | recognition standards set by the State Board, and if the |
| 15 | | district, in accordance with: (a) generally accepted |
| 16 | | Government Auditing Standards issued by the Comptroller |
| 17 | | General of the United States, (b) auditing standards |
| 18 | | established by the American Institute of Certified Public |
| 19 | | Accountants, or (c) other applicable State and federal |
| 20 | | standards, is found by the district's auditor or the State |
| 21 | | Board working in cooperation with the district's auditor to |
| 22 | | have material deficiencies in the design or operation of |
| 23 | | financial control structures that could adversely affect the |
| 24 | | district's financial integrity and stability, or is found to |
| 25 | | have misused State or federal funds and jeopardized its |
| 26 | | participation in State or federal programs, the State Board |
|
| | 10400SB2202sam003 | - 11 - | LRB104 10374 AAS 36815 a |
|
|
| 1 | | may, notwithstanding any laws to the contrary, implement one |
| 2 | | or more of the following emergency powers: |
| 3 | | (1) To direct the district to develop and implement a |
| 4 | | plan that addresses the budgetary, programmatic, and other |
| 5 | | relevant factors contributing to the need to implement |
| 6 | | emergency measures. The State Board shall assist in the |
| 7 | | development and shall have final approval of the plan. |
| 8 | | (2) To direct the district to contract for educational |
| 9 | | services in accordance with Section 3-40. The State Board |
| 10 | | shall assist in the development and shall have final |
| 11 | | approval of any such contractual agreements. |
| 12 | | (3) To approve and require revisions of the district's |
| 13 | | budget. |
| 14 | | (4) To appoint a Financial Administrator to exercise |
| 15 | | oversight and control over the district's budget. The |
| 16 | | Financial Administrator shall serve at the pleasure of the |
| 17 | | State Board and may be an individual, partnership, |
| 18 | | corporation, including an accounting firm, or other entity |
| 19 | | determined by the State Board to be qualified to serve, |
| 20 | | and shall be entitled to compensation. Such compensation |
| 21 | | shall be provided through specific appropriations made to |
| 22 | | the State Board for that express purpose. |
| 23 | | (5) To develop and implement a plan providing for the |
| 24 | | dissolution or reorganization of the district if in the |
| 25 | | judgment of the State Board the circumstances so require. |
| 26 | | All local funds under the control of the State Board as a |